Skip to main content

๐Ÿ“– Chapter 9: Debriefing Your Challenge โ€“ How To Make Every Round More Successful

The complete guide to professionally debriefing your first challenge

Jordan Plotkin avatar
Written by Jordan Plotkin
Updated over 2 months ago

The Story That Keeps Repeating Itself

Your challenge is over.
87 people completed it out of 127 who started.

You feel good.
โ€œ68% completion rate โ€“ not bad!โ€

But then you ask yourself:

  • Why did 40 people drop out?

  • On which day did most people stop showing up?

  • Which content worked best?

  • How can I improve this for next time?

And you have no answers.

You did not analyze the data.
You did not ask your participants.

Result?

Challenge #2 will look exactly like Challenge #1 โ€“
same problems, same weak points, same mistakes.

Smart creators?

They run a deep debrief after every single challenge.

They learn from the data.
They understand what worked and what did not.

And their next challenge?
โ€‹2x better.

In this chapter you will learn:

  • How to collect data during your challenge

  • How to analyze that data after the challenge

  • How to run a debrief with your participants

  • How to identify weak points and drop off points

  • How to improve your next challenge based on real learning

  • How to turn every challenge into a continuous improvement engine


๐Ÿ“Š Collecting Data During The Challenge โ€“ What Should You Measure?

Golden rule:
You cannot improve what you do not measure.

CommuniPass already shows you who opened the content each day.
Your job is to take that data and organize it โ€“ for example, in an Excel or Google Sheet.


1. Daily Open Rate โ€“ Who Actually Opens The Content?

Export or write down how many people opened each dayโ€™s content.

Example table:

Day

Opened

Did Not Open

Open Rate

1

125

2

98%

2

118

9

93%

3

110

17

87%

7

95

32

75%

14

78

49

61%

21

68

59

54%

What this tells you:

  • Days 1โ€“3: almost everyone opens โ†’ strong start โœ…

  • Day 7: drop to 75% โ†’ turning point โš ๏ธ

  • Days 14โ€“21: continued decline โ†’ a large group dropped off โŒ

Conclusions:

  • You need to strengthen days 7โ€“10 โ€“ these are critical days.

  • Maybe the challenge is too long? You might consider shortening it (for example from 21 to 14 days).


2. Group Engagement Rate โ€“ Who Actually Participates?

What this is:
How many people actually share their tasks or post in the group.

How to collect it:

  • Each day, count how many posts/shares were made in the group.

  • Look at who shares a lot and who never shares.

Example:

Day

Shares In Group

% Of Participants

1

85

67%

2

72

57%

3

65

51%

7

45

35%

14

28

22%

21

15

12%

What this tells you:

  • Day 1 โ€“ very high engagement

  • By day 7 โ€“ down to 35%

  • By day 21 โ€“ only 12% of people are sharing

Conclusions:

  • The group โ€œdiesโ€ in the middle โ†’ you need to encourage more sharing.

  • Maybe the tasks are not interesting enough to share?

  • Maybe you should give incentives for sharing (prizes, shoutouts etc.).


3. Responses To Follow-Up Questions

What this is:
If you added follow-up questions at the end of each day, you can see who responded.

Example questions:

  • โ€œDid you complete todayโ€™s task? Yes / Noโ€

  • โ€œWhat was your biggest difficulty today?โ€

  • โ€œWhat did you learn today?โ€

Example table:

Day

Answered The Question

% Of Those Who Opened

1

95

76%

3

78

71%

7

52

55%

14

31

40%

What this tells you:

  • Day 1 โ€“ people are very engaged (76% answer).

  • Day 14 โ€“ only 40% answer โ†’ engagement clearly dropped.

Conclusions:

  • You may want to make the questions more interesting.

  • You may want to give a small incentive for people who answer every day.


5. Drop-Off Points โ€“ When Do People Leave?

What this is:
On which day did most people stop opening content?

How to identify it:

  • Look at your โ€œdaily open rateโ€ table.

  • Find the day with the sharpest drop compared to the previous day.

Example:

Day

Opened

Change From Previous Day

1

127

โ€“

2

122

-5

3

115

-7

4

108

-7

5

101

-7

6

95

-6

7

82

-13 โš ๏ธ

8

78

-4

What this tells you:

  • Day 7 is the sharpest drop: -13 people in one day.

  • Something happened around day 6โ€“7.

Conclusions:

  • Check what content and task you had on days 6โ€“7.

  • Maybe the task was too hard?

  • Maybe the content was boring?

  • Maybe this was the weekend and people were busy?

Action for next challenge:
Strengthen days 6โ€“7 with especially engaging content.


Summary โ€“ What Should You Measure During The Challenge?

โœ… Daily open rate
โœ… Group engagement
โœ… View / read time (where relevant)
โœ… Responses to follow-up questions
โœ… Drop-off points

These numbers show you what happened.
In the next part, you will see how to understand why it happened.


๐Ÿ—ฃ๏ธ Debrief With Participants โ€“ How To Get Real Feedback

The data tells you what happened.
Only your participants can tell you why it happened.

When Should You Run A Debrief?

You have two main options:

  1. During the challenge

    • Send a short survey:
      โ€œHow is it going so far?โ€

  2. After the challenge

    • Send a more complete survey:
      โ€œWhat did you think about the challenge?โ€

Recommended: do both.

  • During the challenge โ€“ you can fix things in real time.

  • After the challenge โ€“ you can improve the next round.


Whatโ€™s Next?

There is no โ€œnext chapterโ€.

Now it is time to:

  • Plan

  • Build

  • Launch your first challenge

Or your next one โ€“ but this time, with real debriefing and improvement.

Good luck. ๐ŸŽฅ

Did this answer your question?